Empowering Women in Leadership: Barriers Preventing Success. 2020 versus 2023.

In March 2020, Resilient Leaders Consultants embarked on a mission to uncover the pivotal challenges that continue to hinder the journey of women towards achieving their full leadership potential. With a dedicated focus on Women in Leadership, we launched a comprehensive questionnaire aimed at shedding light on the obstacles that stand between women and their aspirations. The results revealed a complex interplay of internal and external barriers that are commonly shared with those women we work with and support.  

Mckinsey highlights increases in women in C-Suite positions from 29% in 2015 to 44% in 2019, this is great news. They also highlight that for every 100 men that are promoted to management, only 72 women are promoted (see Mckinsey Report – How diversity wins and inclusion matters – McKinsey 2020). This could certainly be better. We know things are happening but it’s not all about what others can do for us, as female leaders, we have to control the controllables. What can we do for ourselves, to develop, so that we can step up and lead when we need to, to have the confidence and the voice so we can be heard, alongside the self-belief in ourselves to take that step forward?  

How can we as Resilient Leaders Consultants support Women Leaders in having confidence in who they are and what they do, so they can lead themselves, their families, their teams, their organisations with self-belief and conviction?

Our Survey

Since our initial survey in 2020, we stand at a crossroads of progress and change. Our commitment to fostering gender equality and propelling women’s leadership roles forward has only grown stronger. Following our most recent survey in March 2023, we unveil our latest findings – a culmination of further research and expanded questionnaires that delve deeper into the intricacies of the challenges faced by women pursuing leadership roles.

Over a collection of blogs, we revisit the 7 key barriers that were identified in 2020, barriers we focus on within our 3-month Resilient Women Leaders programme, the challenges faced and examine whether the landscape has evolved, or if the foundations of these challenges persist. From internal struggles that often arise from deeply ingrained societal norms to external hurdles rooted in systemic biases, our goal remains steadfast: to drive a meaningful dialogue that sparks change, empowers resilience, and ultimately paves the way for a more inclusive and equitable future.

It has to start with self.

In this blog post, we’ll delve into the original findings and contrast them with our latest research, presenting insights that can guide organisations, individuals, and policymakers alike in fostering an environment where women can truly thrive.

Our research group

Our research group is a diverse and dynamic collective of women, encompassing a broad spectrum of ages, backgrounds, and professional fields. This diverse amalgamation of voices lends depth to our research, ensuring that the findings encapsulate the challenges and triumphs of women across different ages, employment statuses, and industries, with a diverse range of life stages:-

  • Transitioning into new and senior roles, be it as middle managers, executives, or non-executive directors, navigating the responsibilities and opportunities that come with these positions
  • Peri-menopausal and menopausal phase, a pivotal time that demands attention to physical, mental, and emotional health
  • Moving from traditional employment to the realm of self-employment, marked by entrepreneurial spirit and the pursuit of autonomy
  • Transitioning or retiring from the workplace, emphasising the importance of a graceful exit and the complexities of defining new life chapters.
  • Returning to work, balancing career ambitions with evolving personal roles
  • Early career progression, symbolising the promising beginnings that lay the foundation for tomorrow’s leaders

Navigating the intricate landscape of women’s leadership journeys demands a multifaceted approach from coaches, consultants, team leaders, and organisations alike. The comparative insights from our 2020 and 2023 questionnaires provide invaluable guidance on how to support women in breaking down the barriers that persist.

What has our research told us?

First and foremost, both years emphasise the paramount importance of addressing self-belief and imposter syndrome. To combat these internal challenges, it’s imperative to cultivate environments that nurture confidence and empower women to recognise and embrace their worth. Encouraging self-reflection, setting achievable goals, and celebrating accomplishments can bolster self-confidence.

Secondly, the consistent presence of “Lack of Confidence” across both years underscores the need for ongoing efforts to build women’s self-assurance. Offering mentorship, training, and opportunities for skill development can be instrumental in bolstering women’s belief.

“Finding your Voice” and “Being Heard in the Workplace” emerge as noteworthy concerns in 2023. This indicates a need for creating spaces where women’s perspectives are not only welcomed but actively sought. Fostering inclusive communication practices, advocating for active participation, and addressing unconscious bias in decision-making processes can enhance the voices of women in various professional settings.

The shift from a “Narrow Traditional View of Leadership” in 2020 to a “Narrow, Hierarchical View of Leadership” in 2023 highlights the evolving nature of this challenge. Encouraging diverse leadership styles and acknowledging the value of collaborative and inclusive leadership models can counter these limitations.

Effective support mechanisms become pivotal as indicated by the introduction of “Lack of Effective Support” in 2023. Coaches, consultants, and organisations should prioritise mentorship, peer networks, and resources that offer guidance and encouragement throughout women’s leadership journeys.

The enduring presence of “Unconscious Bias” underscores the necessity for ongoing training and education to raise awareness and counter these biases. Moreover, creating an “Unfavourable Working Environment (Physically and Culturally)” in 2023 emphasises the significance of safe, inclusive, and empowering workplaces that promote well-being and value diverse experiences.

Lastly, “Lack of Commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion” and “Lack of Appreciation of Emotional Intelligence in the Workplace” are common threads. This calls for a commitment to structural changes that prioritise diversity and emotional intelligence as cornerstones of effective leadership and organisational success.

As we delve into the dynamics of women’s leadership journeys, it’s clear that despite progress, certain barriers persist. While the 2020 survey provided a foundational understanding, the 2023 survey demonstrates the need for continued dialogue, advocacy, and structural changes to ensure that women are not only recognised for their potential but empowered to shatter the glass ceilings that persist in various forms. By addressing these challenges, coaches, consultants, team, and organisational leaders can actively contribute to dismantling the barriers that hinder women’s progress and pave the way for a more inclusive and equitable future.

What Next?

Both male and female leaders possess the agency to proactively shape their personal growth and dismantle barriers, both personal and within their organisations. The key lies in prioritising continuous leadership development while cultivating an acute understanding of their unique leadership styles, their influence, and the potency of their communication. The Resilient Leaders Elements framework emerges as an indispensable resource, offering a blueprint to bolster self-assurance in both identity and actions, thereby nurturing the emotional and cognitive dimensions of leadership. By embracing the four essential elements:- Clarity of Direction, Awareness, Leadership Presence, and Resilient Decision Making, leaders forge a pathway to recognise their strengths, navigate developmental areas, and traverse the nuanced realm from pressure to resilience. Armed with unwavering self-belief and fortified by this framework, leaders, regardless of gender, sow the seeds of success within themselves and amongst their peers, fostering a culture of inclusive growth, unearthing opportunities, and demonstrating an unwavering ability to surmount even the most daunting of challenges, ushering their teams and organisations towards thriving through uncertainty, change, and adversity.

For further information of how TLRdynamics and Resilient Women Leaders can support you in your next steps, we’d love to hear from you.