Empowering Women Leaders: Lack of Confidence and Self-Belief

Welcome to the second instalment of our ‘Empowering Women Leaders’ series. In this blog, we delve into the intriguing world of barriers that have hindered women from reaching their full potential. We’ve combed through our data archives, starting from 2020, to uncover the order in which internal barriers (IB) and external barriers (EB) were rated by women when asked what prevented them from achieving their full potential. The results are illuminating, revealing not only the barriers that persist but also some new challenges that emerged post-Covid. We’ll explore how these barriers have evolved, discuss some of the reasons behind these shifts, and share insights on how we can collectively overcome them.

Since 2020, we focused on internal barriers (IB) and external barriers (EB) when reviewing our survey results, but going back into the archive, we wanted to see in which order these were rated. When considering the data of those scoring  ‘A lot’ or ‘A great deal’ when asked which barriers prevented them from reaching their full potential, this is what we found.

Data from 2020

RatedBarrierAverageRangeHighest Scoring Group
1Lack of confidence (IB)76%50% – 100% (50)Early Career
2Being heard (IB)71%56% – 83% 27Returning to Work
3Lack of understanding of the importance of emotional intelligence (EB)65%47% – 73% (26)Returning to Work
4Unconscious bias (EB)61%35% – 78% (43)Returning to Work
5Imposter syndrome (IB)59%53% – 65% (12)Transitioning into more Senior Roles
6Lack of commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion (EB)43%24% – 59% (36)Returning to Work
7Narrow view of Leadership (EB)41%24% – 53% (29)Transitioning into more Senior Roles

What we found?

It was interesting to see how the barriers were rated, based on the average score. With ‘Lack of confidence’ and ‘Being heard’ at the top of that list. What was then interesting to see was the barrier that had the smallest range, telling us that a higher number of women, irrelevant of the stage in their careers, were affected by this barrier. With this in mind, ‘Imposter syndrome & self-belief’ stood out as it only had a range of 12, compared to ‘Lack of confidence’ whose range was 50, therefore pushing it up our ‘Top Barrier’ Chart.

I am no statistician or research guru so there will be many variables within this data, which we shall investigate further across the blog series, but so far, it’s great to start a conversation and start to see some common threads.

Did Covid change our perspective?

Following Covid, we were interested in discovering if anything had changed  (with a few additional barriers that were raised during this survey too.)

RatedBarrierAverageRangeHighest Scoring Group
1Narrow, hierarchical, view of Leadership (EB)71%57% – 84% (27)Returning to Work
2Lack of confidence (IB)66%44% – 78% (33)Early Careers
3Imposter syndrome & Self-belief (IB)63%39% – 74% (35)Employment to Self-Employment
4Lack of appreciation of emotional intelligence in the workplace (EB)62%31% – 84% (12)Returning to Work
5Unconscious bias (EB)58%38% – 70% (32)Employment to Self-Employment
6An unfavourable working environment (physically and culturally) (EB)52%33% – 93% (60)Early Careers
7Not being seen or heard in the workplace (EB)50%38% – 62% (23)Early Careers
8Lack of effective support in the workplace (EB)50%42% – 58% (16)Returning to Work
9Finding your voice (IB)41%9% – 67% (58)Early Careers
10Lack of commitment to diversity, equity and inclusion (EB)32%0% – 63% (63)Returning to Work

What we found.

‘Lack of confidence‘ is still near the top, with a reduced average of 66% and, a much smaller range. Therefore showing that more of our women are feeling greater issues with their confidence post-Covid. ‘Imposter syndrome and self-belief‘ is rated 3, with an increased average of 63%, although the range of scores has now increased too.

When we looked at our anecdotal results when asked ‘what are the biggest challenges you are facing at the moment’, the three biggest barriers facing women at different stages of work were clear. Here were our findings:-

  1. Confidence and Self-belief: Women face challenges related to confidence and self-belief throughout their careers. This includes imposter syndrome, fear of the unknown, and doubting their capabilities. It can be difficult for women to realise that everyone is watching and that their actions and habits greatly impact their professional growth
  2. Work-life balance and family responsibilities: Balancing work and family responsibilities is a significant barrier for women, especially as they progress in their careers. Juggling childcare, managing aging parents and finding the right fit in terms of job role, hours and pay can be challenging. Women may struggle with finding time for themselves and remembering that their own needs are important.
  3. Gender Bias and Male-Dominated Environments: Women often face barriers in male-dominated industries and workplaces. Dealing with unconscious bias, lack of support, and a perception that women are less capable or should be paid less can hinder career progression.

The anecdotal results underline this barrier of lack of confidence and also imposter syndrome and self-belief, amongst so many other things too, (again for another blog!). It is clear we still need to focus in this area when supporting women with their development.

Going back to our 2023 results table, we can’t ignore the new No.1 Barrier that stood out in 2023. Since Covid to the top of our barrier list……’A narrow hierarchical view of leadership.’ From our lowest barrier in 2020 to now our highest in 2023. Why?

Here is one view, of which there are many.

Covid and the change in our Leadership

We know that when you’re not confident in who you are and what you do, your leadership response may waiver. In a crisis, the urgency of a situation and the rate at which we have to make decisions increases. If we lack awareness of our own behaviours, our own styles, our own strengths and weaknesses, we may end up making terrible decisions affecting both individuals, teams and the organisation. We may not have the tools to know how we can adapt our leadership styles depending on the level of urgency either.

Things that can affect our decision-making

  • As a leader, we think we should make all decisions, therefore we’re not bringing in a mix of perspectives so our decisions are not well-informed / robust
  • As a leader, we feel guilty about delegating, therefore taking on more work than we should leading to a feeling of overwhelm
  • As a leader, we may micromanage due to our need of control, therefore not enabling others and growing their capabilities
  • As a leader, we aren’t looking after ourselves because that takes time away from work, therefore we may not be performing at our best
  • As a leader, we don’t have time to build relationships with our team and find out their strengths, therefore how do we know that we’re getting the best from our team
  • As a leader, we are trying to be the leader we think we should be rather than the leader we authentically are, therefore trust, accountability and commitment is affected within your team.

Crisis can bring out our true behaviours and if we’ve not spent time understanding what they are, on a good day, when we’re high performing AS WELL as on a bad day when we’re moving from pressure to stress, we won’t have the tools from which to draw upon to support us in these time.

We can start to understand some of the reasons why some companies and workplaces have changed the way they lead, due to their focus on keeping the company moving forward, whether they have done it in a way that has benefited or caused more crisis. Our data doesn’t tell us that, we can only speculate.

And maybe this isn’t the reason at all, why this barrier has now escalated itself to the top. I’d love to hear your thoughts and speculations too.

So What

Working with women, as part of our Resilient Women Leaders 3-month programme, which runs 3 times a year, it is clear from our results that if we can:-

  • increase confidence in who you are and what you do
  • increase self-belief in your strengths and areas of development
  • understand your impact on others
  • be comfortable asking for help, showing vulnerability and therefore creating trust
  • increase understanding in the importance of Clarity of Direction and your role in clear communication

Many of these barriers disappear because, through the programme,  we find our voice, we are able to articulate who we are and what we do to our colleagues and managers. It’s this that builds trust with those we work with, creating a positive environment from which to work and for others to thrive. Our resilience grows and we have the capacity to cope for much longer.

Whatever your barriers, whatever your role and wherever you are in your career journey, invest time in yourself so that you are fully tooled up to lead through whatever crisis comes your way, large or small, professional or personal.

For further information on how TLRdynamics Ltd and Resilient Women Leaders can support you in your next steps, we’d love to hear from you.

About TLRdynamics Ltd

TLRdynamics (Team Leadership and Resilience), focuses on providing support to allow businesses to discover and improve their organisational health. Working with individuals, teams and companies from all sectors, to diagnose key obstacles, bringing greater clarity, cohesion, communication and consistency, where it is needed the most, creating an environment for all to thrive. By tackling the often-underlying symptoms, our focus is on prevention rather than cure.

About Resilient Women Leaders

Alex Webb and Skye Deane founded Resilient Women Leaders in November 2020, following research that established the most commonly shared barriers that kept women from reaching their full potential. As Resilient Leaders Consultants, they knew how impactful the Resilient Leaders Elements™ framework was at supporting growth and development in overcoming these barriers, internal and external. Now delivering 2 open virtual programmes for women across career stages and industries, Resilient Women Leaders (3-month programme), run 3 times per year and ReNew You (5 weeks, 1 hour per week), run 4 times per year. Alex and Skye provide a safe, confidential and non-judgemental space for individuals to explore, share and work through the challenges they are facing. Knowing that, to build resilience, we need to be proactive and not just reactive. An average of 23% growth in just 3 months of development.